Il Corsaro is sometimes held up as an example of one of Verdi's "galley works," and to some extent it deserves this appellation. But like many of Verdi's early works, it suffers most by comparison with his later works—when viewed on its own, it has more than a few redeeming assets. Even viewed within the context of his entire output, the moments of genuine creativity or powerful dramatic effect are strong indications of what Verdi would later accomplish.

Medora's opening aria, to a harp accompaniment, is particularly effective when performed by a soprano without any fears of the sometimes unusual intervals or the highly exposed lines, and Corrado's prison-scene aria is warmly lyrical. Most of the rest of the music is standard late bel canto, consisting of good, solid, cliched, and predictable set pieces. They are well-crafted and have a foot-stomping appeal (particularly in Gulnara's music, such as her duets with Corrado and Seid, which point the admittedly long way to Eboli and Amneris). Looking at just the score, the opera is somewhat disappointing, considering the superb work Verdi had already done in Macbeth. Ernani, and Nabucco, to name its most successful predecessors. But in performance or on recordings, it is definitely worth attention.

© All Music Guide

Portions of Content Provided by All Music Guide.
© 2008 All Media Guide, LLC. All Music Guide is a registered trademark of All Media Guide, LLC.